Nobody is entirely certain where. The field known as Gort an Bhráthar, meaning roughly the friar's garden or field, preserves the memory of a religious site, but the building itself has dissolved so thoroughly into the landscape that its precise footprint remains unconfirmed. What survives is a scattering of clues: low grassy mounds where walls once rose, an irregular spread of collapsed stonework about 12 metres south of the field, and a single carved architectural fragment wedged into a field boundary where it was presumably reused as building material.

The most eloquent of these fragments is a section of a round-headed doorway arch, cut from sandstone and finished with punch dressing, a technique in which the stone surface is worked with a pointed tool to produce a textured finish. The arch head is chamfered, meaning its edges are cut at an angle, a detail that points to some ambition in the original structure. The writer known as An Seabhac first drew attention to possible ruins here in 1939, and by 1953 the Co. Kerry Field Club had recorded that the north-west corner of a building had been absorbed into a field fence, with the north and south walls still faintly legible as low earthen ridges. Two other dressed stones were uncovered alongside the doorway fragment at some point, but both have since disappeared. The doorway section itself survived only because it was pressed into service in a fence line, which is, in its own way, an accidental form of preservation.

The site has yielded other material too, though not all of it points straightforwardly to a church. A shell midden, the compressed refuse of shellfish consumption associated with early settlement and feasting, was found in the southern corner of Gort an Bhráthar. A decorated bronze object, catalogued by the National Museum of Ireland as NMI 1931:103, was also recovered nearby. Together these finds suggest the area carried human significance across a considerable span of time, though whether the church was early medieval or later in date remains, like its exact location, an open question.