The site is listed among Ireland's catalogued monuments, but the details that would ordinarily accompany such a listing, the founding date, the order that built it, the sequence of use and abandonment, have not yet been made publicly available. What can be said is that the town itself has a long ecclesiastical history, and an abbey in this location would fit a broader pattern of medieval religious settlement across the midlands and west of Ireland, where Augustinian, Carmelite, and Dominican houses were established from the twelfth century onward, often under the patronage of Anglo-Norman lords seeking to consolidate their landholdings through acts of religious foundation.

Loughrea was granted to Richard de Burgo in the late thirteenth century, and the town that grew around his castle became a significant Anglo-Norman centre in Connacht. A Carmelite friary was founded there in 1300, and the town's religious character deepened over subsequent centuries. Whether the abbey recorded as a monument is connected to that Carmelite foundation, or represents a distinct and separate site, is precisely the kind of question that the available record cannot yet answer. It is a placeholder for a history that exists somewhere in the physical landscape and the archival record, waiting to be more fully described.