No grave markers remain, no enclosure wall, no visible boundary of any kind. The only evidence that something was ever here is a single appearance on the Ordnance Survey six-inch map of 1842, where a broken oval line traces an enclosure roughly 110 metres along its north-east to south-west axis and around 18 metres across at its widest. A lane ran parallel to and just inside the north-western edge, occupying about half the width of the enclosure. That lane is now disused and overgrown toward the south-east. The place persists in local memory under the name Old Aghinagh burial ground, which is perhaps the most substantial thing left of it.

The 1842 OS map was part of the first systematic large-scale survey of Ireland, carried out in the decades following the Act of Union, and its surveyors had a habit of recording things, field boundaries, ruins, earthworks, and defunct roads, that were already fading when they passed through. The fact that this burial ground appears only on that single survey, depicted with a broken rather than solid line, suggests it was already indistinct or partially lost by the time the cartographers reached Inchaleagh. The Aghinagh district, centred on the valley of the upper River Lee, had its own parish history predating the rationalisation of Catholic and Church of Ireland administrative boundaries in the nineteenth century, and old burial grounds in such areas often reflect earlier patterns of community and devotion that did not survive into the modern period. A site known locally but invisible on the ground occupies a particular category, remembered but not marked, present in name only.