The earlier church was recorded as being in repair in 1615, which suggests it was still functioning at that point, however modestly, during a period when the religious landscape of Munster was being reshaped in the aftermath of the Tudor plantations and the slow, uneven spread of the reformed church across County Cork.

The 1615 reference comes from Brady's record of Irish ecclesiastical sites, a nineteenth-century source that captured details of medieval and early modern church buildings across the country, many of which were already ruinous or repurposed by the time Brady was writing. The fact that this particular church was noted as being in repair rather than in ruins suggests it retained some practical use at that moment, though whatever structure existed there was evidently absorbed or replaced entirely when the Church of Ireland building was erected on the same spot. That later church now stands as the only visible presence on the site, with nothing of the earlier fabric surviving at ground level.