The building that stands today is not the medieval original, and that gap between what was and what remains is where most of the interest lies.

The site first appears in written record in a decretal letter of 1199, a form of papal correspondence used to settle ecclesiastical disputes or establish legal precedents, though it is not until 1306 that any document clearly identifies it as a functioning parish church. A map drawn by Hardiman around 1601 gives a rare visual impression of the medieval building: a simple, single-naved structure with no aisles, no transepts, and no tower, modest even by the standards of urban parish churches of the period. That building was demolished in 1782, and its replacement was constructed between 1785 and 1788, with a tower added to the eastern end in 1838. The replacement church has since been repurposed as a store, leaving the building in a quietly anomalous position: architecturally Georgian, historically medieval, and functionally neither. To the west of the current structure, the remains of the earlier graveyard survive, a physical trace of the site's longer continuity of use across the various phases of building and demolition.