No headstone, no wall fragment, no earthwork survives to suggest that anything of significance ever occupied the spot. The erasure appears to be recent, a levelling of whatever remained, leaving a site that is now legible only on paper.

The 1842 Ordnance Survey six-inch map records the location as a hachured circle, roughly fifteen metres in diameter, labelled both 'Grave Yard' and '(site of) church'. The use of 'site of' is telling; even by the mid-nineteenth century, the structures themselves were already gone, reduced to a known position rather than a standing presence. Later editions of the same map repeated the designation without adding anything new. The site has been tentatively associated with St. Catherine's parish church, a candidate raised by O'Donoghue in 1986, though the identification is uncertain. Other researchers have placed St. Catherine's closer to North Gate Bridge, on the opposite side of the city's historic northern approach, which leaves the Garranabraher site without a firm ecclesiastical biography. What it once was, and when it fell out of use, remains unresolved.