It sits, or possibly sits, within a children's burial ground, and there is nothing at ground level to confirm it ever existed. What makes this absence unusual is that it is a contested absence, one that people have been arguing over, circling around, and performing rituals beside for well over a century.

The tension between evidence and tradition here is neatly captured by two sources that flatly contradict each other. Writing in 1906, a researcher named Cooke declared that there was no trace of any building or ruin of any old church at the site or anywhere nearby. Yet by the 1940s, accounts recorded through the Kerry Field Club described pilgrims conducting the "rounds" at Kilclogherane, a traditional form of devotional walking in which participants move clockwise around a sacred site, pausing to pray at fixed points. Those accounts noted that the pilgrims processed around what was probably the remains of an ancient church of fairly large dimensions. The same decade, a Schools Manuscript entry described the place as an old ruin surrounded by a burial ground. Whether the structure had simply become less visible between 1906 and the 1940s, or whether the pilgrims were walking a circuit shaped more by memory and custom than by any physical remains, is unclear. Alongside these conflicting accounts sits a local tradition that a colony of saints and monks once lived at Kilclogherane and were afterwards transferred to Muckross, the Franciscan abbey on the shores of Lough Leane near Killarney, founded in the fifteenth century. That detail, if it holds any weight, would push the origins of the community here back considerably further.

What remains on the ground today is the children's burial ground itself, a site of the kind known in Ireland as a cillín, where unbaptised infants and others excluded from consecrated ground were quietly interred, often at locations already understood to carry some older sacred significance. The possible church beneath it, if there is one, has yet to be confirmed.