The later building, raised in 1805, sits in the southern half of the enclosure, positioned deliberately to the south of a still-older church that preceded it on the same ground. That layering, a working congregation setting down a new place of worship without entirely abandoning the footprint of the old, gives the site a quietly doubled character that is easy to miss without knowing what to look for.

The 1805 church is a modest but considered piece of early nineteenth-century ecclesiastical building. Its nave is lit by slender pointed windows set into both the north and south walls, a restrained Gothic touch common to Protestant churches of the period in rural Ireland. A vestry projects from the north wall, and the west end is finished with an embattled tower, that is, one with a crenellated parapet of the kind more usually associated with medieval fortifications, though by the early 1800s it had become a fairly conventional way to give a rural church a degree of gravity and presence. An apse, the curved recess at the east end that typically shelters the altar, was added later, extending the original plan and giving the building its current elongated form. The reference to Brady's 1863 survey confirms the church was well established and recorded within a few decades of its construction, with the earlier structure already noted as a distinct and separate feature of the same site.