No structure marks the spot, no stonework frames the source, and yet the site carries enough weight that cartographers recording Ireland in the 1840s thought it worth naming. The Ordnance Survey's six-inch map of 1842 labels it Lady's Well, placing it in a tradition of Marian dedication found at hundreds of similar sites across the country, where natural springs were associated with the Virgin Mary, often layering older patterns of veneration onto a Christianised landscape.

What survives is essentially the name and the location. No physical remains of the well itself have been recorded, which is not uncommon for sites of this type; many holy wells were never elaborate structures to begin with, and those that were have frequently been obscured by grazing, drainage works, or simply the slow accumulation of time. The well at Creagh sits in its field on a slope that would have made the emerging water visible and accessible, a practical quality that often determined where such sites took hold. A short distance to the west stands the ruin of a church, a proximity that is unlikely to be coincidental. Sacred sites in Ireland frequently cluster in this way, with well and church reinforcing one another's significance across centuries of use.