No walls remain, no arch, no floor plan visible above ground. What survives is the inference: a position on a map, a burial ground that kept its outline, and a sixty-year window in the historical record during which the building went from functional to entirely vanished.

The evidence for the church rests largely on the Down Survey, a remarkable mid-seventeenth-century mapping project commissioned under Oliver Cromwell to document landholding across Ireland in extraordinary detail. The survey's map, dated to 1652, places a church at this precise location, and that correspondence with the existing graveyard is what leads historians to identify the site as the medieval parish church of Caheragh. A note recorded by Brady in 1867 adds a little more texture: the church was still in repair in 1639, suggesting it was at least structurally sound in the years before the upheavals of the 1640s, but by 1699 it had disappeared altogether. Sixty years, and nothing left. Whether it fell to neglect, deliberate demolition, or the slow pilfering of dressed stone for other buildings, as so often happened with abandoned churches across rural Ireland, the record does not say.